When you think of classic cartoon heroes, Popeye the Sailor stands tall (pipe in mouth, muscles flexed, spinach in hand). He first appeared in the funny pages back in 1929, and for nearly a century he’s been punching bad guys, mumbling one-liners, and reminding kids to eat their greens.
But here’s the question that’s floated around for years: was Popeye a real person?
Popeye was created by cartoonist Elzie Crisler Segar, who introduced him in his comic strip Thimble Theatre. What started as a side character quickly took over the strip and became one of the most famous cartoon characters in the world.
Segar always claimed Popeye was pure imagination — a sailor with grit, luck, and a can of spinach. But locals in Segar’s hometown had a different story.
Segar grew up in Chester, Illinois, and in that town there was a sailor named Frank “Rocky” Fiegel. Fiegel was a gruff, pipe-smoking bartender known for his big chin, his quick fists, and his habit of defending locals when fights broke out. Sound familiar?
Fiegel wasn’t a sailor, but he looked and acted the part. Many in Chester believed he was the model for Popeye, even if Segar never outright confirmed it. The town has since embraced the connection — Chester even has a Popeye statue honoring both the character and his supposed real-life inspiration.
He was born in 1868, in Poland and, as a child, immigrated to the United States with his parents, who settled down in a small town in Illinois. As a young man, Rocky went to sea. After a 20-year career as a sailor in the Merchant Marines, Fiegel retired.
He was later hired by Wiebusch’s Tavern in the city of Chester, Illinois as a ‘Bouncer’ to maintain order in the rowdy bar. Rocky quickly developed a reputation for always being involved in fighting (and usually winning). As a result, he had a deformed eye (“Pop-eye”). He also ‘always’ smoked his pipe, so he always spoke out of one side of his mouth.
In his spare time as a bouncer, Rocky would entertain the customers by regaling them with exciting stories of adventures he claimed to have had over his career as a sailor crossing the ‘Seven Seas.’
The creator of Popeye, Elzie Crisler Segar, grew up in Chester and, as a young man, met Rocky at the tavern and would sit for hours listening to the old sailor’s amazing ‘sea stories.’
Years later, Segar became a cartoonist and developed a comic strip called ‘Thimble Theater.’ He honored Fiegel by asking if he could model his new comic strip character, ‘Popeye the Sailor Man,’ after him. Naturally Fiegel was flattered and agreed.
Segar claimed that ‘Olive Oyl,’ along with other characters, was also loosely based on an actual person. She was Dora Paskel, owner of a small grocery store in Chester. She apparently actually looked much like the Olive Oyl character in his comics. He claimed she even dressed much the same way. Through the years, Segar kept in touch with Rocky and always helped him with money; giving him a small percentage of what he earned from his ‘Popeye’ illustrations.
The spinach part that was Segar’s addition, inspired by the fact that spinach was considered a superfood in the early 20th century. Nutritionists back then praised its iron content, and Segar used it as Popeye’s secret weapon. Sales of spinach actually went up after Popeye became popular — proof that cartoons can move markets.
So, was Popeye a real person?
Well kinda, he was definitely inspired by one. While Segar dreamed up the sailor who fought Bluto and saved Olive Oyl, the swagger and chin probably came from Chester’s own Frank “Rocky” Fiegel.
Popeye lives in that sweet spot between fiction and reality: part comic strip, part small-town legend. And maybe that’s why he’s lasted so long. Because deep down, we like to believe that somewhere out there was a guy tough enough to inspire the sailor man who could do anything with a can of spinach.
Big and Tall Silence of the Lambs T-Shirts for Every Size Fan Some movies just crawl under your skin and stay there. Silence of the
Learn about The Crow and see if it is based on a comic. Discover the impact of its comic book origins on the film’s narrative.
Explore the question: Is Carrie based on a true story? Discover Stephen King’s inspiration behind this iconic novel.
